Strengths and weaknesses of voting systems second inter-american meeting on electoral technology panama city, panama march 1, 2004 introduction. Reform options for the electoral college and the election of the us president (also, be sure to visit our page of frequently asked questions about reform). Electoral college alternatives and us electoral college, this paper does mention some of its strengths and weaknesses the paper also endorses and investigates. And there are certainly alternatives, each with its own set of strengths and weaknesses but we can be sure of one thing the electoral college was the result of careful thought by a group of most enlightened minds. The electoral college preserves the voice of states with lower populations and more rural areas, occupy theory noted especially in contemporary times, urban areas tend to be more populated, but the electoral college saves the interests of farmers and those found in less bustling locations.
Use the compare strengths weaknesses chart strengths of the electoral college: (each of these points maybe more detailed than the teacher needs for class. - the strengths and weaknesses of the system of choosing presidential candidates it seems reasonable to conjecture that the achilles' heel of the modern presidency is one of recruitment the long-winded delegate nomination process could in theory be replaced by a daylong direct election of presidential candidates. Arguments against the electoral college it's too complicated a direct election is simpler—just count up all the votes across the country, and whoever gets the most, wins. A major flaw in the electoral college system is that a candidate could win the popular vote, but lose the election, due to the number of votes per state three main weaknesses of the electoral.
The largest weakness is jefferson's system of having an electoral college elect the president this has led to our unique two party system which allows a president of one party to be elected while the legislative branch of government is controlled by a different party leading to a grid lock situation where government barely functions at all. The biggest weakness of the electoral college is that it gives too much power to the swing states (states with approximately an equal number of voters who are likely to vote democratic and republican) - the reason this is true is that 48 out the 50 states and the washington dc cast their electoral votes on an all or nothing basis - and most are still clearly red states or blue states. Advantages of fptp first past the post, like other plurality/majority electoral systems, is defended primarily on the grounds of simplicity and its tendency to produce winners who are representatives beholden to defined geographic areas and governability. According to jeraine root, historically the electoral college was developed through negotiation deriving from conflicts between representatives at the constitutional convention disagreement came about regarding the strengths and weaknesses of larger or smaller states. The electoral college is in many circumstances defended on the thought that in the process an prompt attractiveness vote the noticeably populated states could abuse their skill against sparsely populated states i discover this a foul argument on 3 grounds a million) in spite of the reality that hispanics are a minority race, as are orientals, no-one has stated it mandatory to grant them.
One of the weaknesses of the constitution is the creation of the electoral college the electoral college consists of the same number of senators and representatives there are 50 senators and at this moment 435 representatives, the district of columbia receives 3 electors therefore there are 538 electors. All the electoral systems have different strengths and weaknesses this essay will look at the strengths and weaknesses of some of these electoral systems while evaluating them against the jenkins criteria, to see if there is such a thing as a âperfect electoral systemâ. Swot (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats) analysis axia college essay sample the business plan is highly-detailed, written statement that explains the purpose of creating a new venture, either a new company or a new project in an existing company which will provide products to customers. Understanding the electoral college october 16, 2000 what are their strengths and weaknesses 7 how can the ec be defended lesson plan: lesson plan: the electoral process.
The constitutional convention the solution was the electoral college the strengths and weaknesses of political parties. Electoral college system weakness small-population states over-represented can this be seen as a bad thing winner takes all system can distort the results. Strengths and weaknesses of the president of the united states place indirectly through an electoral college that has been appointed specifically to elect the. Find an answer to your question the electoral college has many weaknesses several reform plans have been suggested to strengthen these weaknesses strength and. It improves that small states' electoral strength traditionally, it has privileged the republican party by weighing the advantages and disadvantages of electoral college, you should then know where you stand.
1) when electoral college system was established in 1789 it was a worry that if the system was abolished, the votes of their inhabitants would become worthless as larger states such as florid and california take priority. See all government & politics resources » related discussions on the student room gogsoc episode vii: game of moans » ib students: what are your extended essay topics. Presidential elections: the electoral college the electoral college study play articles of confederation strengths and weaknesses 14 terms propositions. Home pros and cons disadvantages and advantages of electoral college disadvantages and advantages of electoral college it has improved the electoral strength of.
Electoral college electoral college do you need help with your school work here at the global writers network we have been helping students like you work smart since 2006. Start studying strengths and weaknesses of the electoral college learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Election shows strength, not weakness, of american democracy any of these other factors relevant—including the electoral college system that still has its merits electoral strength in.